A Silent & Reliable Canister Filter: Which Brand to Trust?

Keeping your aquarium water clear and clean is the goal of every aquarist. Canister aquarium filters are designed to provide superior filtration for just about any size aquarium.

The ability to use a variety of filtration media types coupled with a high volume flow rate equals a powerful water purification system.

My recommended canister filter is the Hydor Professional, continue reading for more!

Aquarium canister filters come with a variety of features suitable for freshwater and saltwater aquariums. We’ll outline the most important features to look for in the best aquarium canister filters for this year.

How aquarium canister filters work

The three stages of aquarium filtration

Important things to look for when selecting an aquarium canister filter


The top six aquarium canister filters

Hydor Professional

The Hydor Professional canister filter series uses a high-quality ceramic shaft on the pump motor.

The impeller, which pumps the water, rotates on the ceramic shaft.

A ceramic shaft ensures smooth, quiet operation of the water pump. The long hoses make it easy to connect the filter and avoid kinking.

The canister comes with individual media baskets complete with mechanical filter pads and biological filtration media.

The Hydor Professional series includes a spray bar attachment. The spray bar tube has a series of holes that spray water across the surface of the water. This provides aeration for the fish. The intake and spray bar tubing and fittings are mounted inside the aquarium with suction cups.

One feature not found on all aquarium canister filters is a priming system. Without a priming system, you’ll have to start the siphon into the canister by sucking on the end of the outlet hose. It’s different with the Hydor.

Simply pump the primer knob and water automatically fills the canister, pushing air out of the canister tank. This makes filter start-up quick and easy. The quick disconnect valves use ball-type mechanisms for smooth, leak-free action.

The Hydor Professional canister filter line does not include activated carbon.

You’ll have to purchase Hydor activated carbon separately.

The Hydor Professional is available in five aquarium-rated sizes - 20-40 gallons, 40-75 gallons, 60-100 gallons, 75-125 gallons and 90-150 gallons. Pump flow rates range from 160 to 290 gallons per hour, depending on the model.

Pros

  • Hydor Professional series is available for a variety of aquarium sizes.
  • Uses a ceramic pump shaft for quiet operation.
  • Has filter media baskets.
  • Easy priming system.

Cons

  • Does not come with activated carbon.
  • Replacement parts are expensive.

API Filstar

The API Filstar line features a patented quick disconnect valve that shuts off both hoses and disconnects from the canister with the flip of a lever.

This makes it quick and easy to carry the canister to the sink for cleaning.

The Filstar canister filter used heavy-duty baskets to hold filtration media.

The filters come with two kinds of foam pads for mechanical filtration.

The coarse foam has a rating of 20 pores per inch to capture large particles. The fine foam pad is rated at 30 pores per inch and captures cloud-causing particulates and algae. The filter also includes Bio-Chem Zorb.

Bio-Chem Zorb is a blend of premium activated carbon and high-performance adsorption resins in a ready to use pouch. Bio-Chem Zorb is an advanced chemical filtration media that keeps aquarium water free of harmful organics.

Also included with the canister filter is biological media called Bio-Chem Stars. Bio-Chem Stars are made of porous plastic specifically made for biological filtration.

The star-shaped media have 50-micron pores, providing protective growing areas for beneficial nitrifying bacteria.

As a bonus, the Filstar comes with a polishing filter pad that makes the water sparkling clear. The canister filter comes complete with six-foot-long hoses and high-quality inlet and outlet fittings.

There are many types of replacement filtration media available including Nitra-Zorb. Nitra-Zorb removes algae-stimulating nitrate from the aquarium water.

Four sizes include Small (up to 45 gallons), Medium (up to 75 gallons), Large (up to 175 gallons) and XL (up to 265 gallons).

Pros

  • Comes complete with all the necessary filtration media.
  • Quiet operation.
  • Easy to change the filtration media.
  • Long hoses.
  • Replacement media comes in ready to use pouches.

Cons

  • Aquarium size recommendations are slightly exaggerated.
  • Does not come with a spray bar.
  • Does not have a self-priming feature.

EHEIM Classic Canister Filters

Eheim is famous for high-quality German-engineered aquarium filters.

The Eheim Classic series is a no-frills aquarium canister filter with only basic features.

The Eheim Classic canister filters do not have media baskets. Filtration material is placed directly inside the canister.

Eheim MECH is a loose mechanical filter media designed to trap debris.

A foam pad is placed on top of the MECH to hold it in place.

The Classic canister line also comes with Eheim SubstratPro, a loose biological media for nitrifying bacteria.

Eheim Classic aquarium canister filters do not come with activated carbon. Eheim activated carbon filter pads are available separately. Loose activated carbon can be poured into a filter bag and placed in the canister if desired.

Cleaning of the filtration media will require collecting the loose MECH and SubstratPro in separate containers for cleaning. This will lengthen the time it takes to service the canister filter. Included with the canister filter is a set of flexible hoses, spray bar, an inlet pipe and suction cups.

Eheim Classic canister filters come with two-piece valves that disconnect for easy filter clean-outs.

The Eheim Classic filter line is rated for aquariums at 40 gallons, 66 gallons, and 92 gallons.

Pros

  • High-quality plastic components.
  • Reliable water pump.
  • Quiet operation.

Cons

  • Limited aquarium sizes.
  • Does not include activated carbon.
  • MECH and SubstratPro do not come in a filter bag.
  • Complicated to service the canister filter with loose media.

Penn Plax Cascade

All Penn Plax Cascade canister filters have plastic media baskets that stack inside the canister.

The Cascade canister filters come in three sizes and are rated for 30 gallons, 65 gallons and 150 gallons.

Penn Plax Cascade filter media consists of sponge pads for trapping debris.

The coarse sponge also supports biological filtration by providing surface area for nitrifying bacterial growth. Ceramic biological filtration rings are supplied in a flow-through pouch. Granular activated carbon is also included in a flow-through pouch.

Changing the filter media is quick and easy. The 360-degree rotating valves spin to comply with the intake and outlet hose angles. The quick disconnect valves make it simple to disconnect the canister from the hoses for servicing. The quick disconnect valves are also used for reducing the water flow rate. This is helpful when feeding.

Canister filters can flush floating food flakes down into the water and get sucked into the filter. Delicate fish sometimes have a difficult time getting food if the water flow is too strong.

The valves can provide a temporary flow reduction while fish are being fed.

The Penn Plax Cascade line feature a one-push priming button on top of the canister. Simply push the button to start the siphon and fill the canister with water.

Four heavy duty locking clamps secure the upper pump house to the canister.

Replacement filter media is available.

The Cascade canister filter comes with all the necessary filter media along with long tubing, inlet and outlets, suction cups and a spray bar.

The Cascade have a three-year warranty.

Pros

  • Comes will all necessary filter media.
  • Three-year warranty.
  • Quick disconnect valves can also reduce flow rate.

Cons

  • Poor customer service.
  • Tubing is somewhat stiff and inflexible.
  • Quality control is poor, some units leak.

Sunsun 4-Stage with 9-watt UV Sterilizer

The Sunsun 4-Stage Canister filter has three filter baskets for holding filtration materials like activated carbon, biological filtration media and foam pads.

The Sunsun 4-Stage Canister Filter comes only with fine and coarse filter pads.

Sunsun offers activated carbon in a flow-through pouch.

One-pound of porous ceramic rings are also available in a filter pouch.

Sunsun plastic biological filtration balls are yet another option when outfitting your canister filter. These can be purchased separately or as a complete kit. The replacement filter media kits offer an economical alternative to purchasing individual filtration media.

The Sunsun is designed with a priming button. Simply press the priming button to fill the canister with water. Then, plug it in and the filter begins pumping immediately.

The priming feature eliminates the need for siphon priming.

The fourth stage of the Sunsun canister filter is a built-in 9-watt ultraviolet (UV) light.

The UV light kills suspended algae that pass through the filter.

When exposed to ultraviolet light the algae cells are killed. This will reduce the chances of an algae bloom and keep the aquarium clear.

The UV light feature also helps reduce pathogenic bacteria and parasites the cause fish diseases. The disinfection properties of UV lights is reduced when the water is dirty.

The dirt particles block the UV rays from striking the microbes and reduce the effectiveness.

The Sunsun 4-Stage places the UV bulb as the last stage of filtration, ensuring only clear water is exposed to the UV light.

The canister includes long hoses, spray bar and suction cups.

Pros

  • Rated for up to 75 gallons.
  • Self-priming.
  • Uses UV light to reduce algae and pathogens.
  • Bulk replacement filter media is available.

Cons

  • Does not come with activated carbon.
  • Does not come with biological filter media.

Fluval FX4 and FX6

The Fluval FX series of canister filters represent a new and innovative approach to canister filter design.

Both filters share the basket-in-a-basket design.

The round media baskets stack on top of one another like other canister filters but there is a difference.

The Fluval FX baskets have an outer basket and an inner basket. Multiple baskets stack and nest together.

With the FX design, the water path follows in a sequential process as it flows through each stage of filtration.

The FX4 has five stages of filtration and the FX6 has six filtration stages.

The filtration media consist of FX pads that capture large particles and debris for effective mechanical filtration, the crucial first stage in the filtration process.

Bio-Foam pads trap fine particles and act as a biological filter media. Biomax biological filter rings are hard, ceramic media with a complex pore system for beneficial bacteria. Carbon impregnated foam pads are pre-cut for Fluval FX canister filters. The carbon impregnated pads capture micro particles, odors, discoloration and organic contaminants.

The Smart Pump technology automatically primes the canister filter. The smart digital pump monitoring system automatically adjusts the pump speed to maintain a consistent flow rate and even purges the canister of trapped air every 12 hours. The Aqua Stop disconnect valves make it easy to change the canister.

The FX4 is rated for aquariums up to 250 gallons and has an actual maximum flow rate of 450 gallons per hour.

The FX6 is rated for aquariums up to 400 gallons and has an actual flow rate of 563 gallons per hour.

Pros

  • High-quality construction.
  • Large sturdy quick disconnect valves.
  • Additional Fluval filter media can be used.
  • Multi-directional output nozzle.
  • Large canister holds plenty of filter media.
  • Made in Italy.

Cons

  • Higher initial cost to purchase than other filters.
  • Takes up a lot of space.
  • Maintenance is complicated due to basket design.

Final recommendations

The API Filstar canister filters are built with thick high-quality plastic components that will hold up over time. This is important as inexpensive thin plastic components can deform over time and cause leaks.

The Filstar canisters use a unique “figure eight” O-ring that forms an especially tight water seal. This ensures the filter primes easily and keeps running with no leaks.

Unlike the Eheim filters, Filstar canisters come with stackable media baskets that allow you to add large amounts of biological filter media, activated carbon and more.

The Filstar canister filters come with premium filtration media. You don’t need to buy anything else to set up the filter. There are also a variety of ready-to-use API filter media available in flow-through pouches.

The Filstar pump motors run silently and are reliable. The Filstar canister filters are available in four sizes for just about any aquarium. Replacement parts are readily available.

The Hydor Professional canister filters are also a top choice. The Hydor professional line, like the Filstar, come with stackable media baskets. The Hydor Professional canisters come with a spray bar. Filstar canister filters have an outlet nozzle but no spray bar. The Hydor Professional also has the automatic priming feature that makes starting up the filter easier.

The UV light feature of the Sunsun canister filter is appealing but is not necessary for every aquarium. It also adds a layer of complexity to the filter and uses more energy.

The Fluval FX series offers the largest canister of the group. The digital motor control and variety of filtration stages makes the FX aquarium canister filters a tech-lovers dream.

While the FX series is more complicated to assemble and maintain, it is a complete filtration package that provides all the necessary features to keep an aquarium well-filtered.

Another nice feature is the true flow rates are provided rather than the unrealistic “ideal” maximum flow rates based on only the pump and not a canister filled with filter media.

Your questions and comments are welcome, please post them below!

Leave a Comment: